Do Algorithm Animations Aid Learning?
نویسندگان
چکیده
Two experiments examined the general claim that animations can help students learn algorithms more effectively. Animations and instructions that explicitly required learners to predict the behavior of an algorithm were used during training. Post-test problems were designed to measure how well learners could predict algorithm behavior in new situations as well as measure learners' conceptual understanding of the algorithms. In Experiment 1, we found that when learners both viewed an animation and made predictions their performance on novel problems improved compared to a control group's, but the effects of the two manipulations were not distinguishable. In Experiment 2, no effect was found for conceptual measures of learning, but a marginally reliable effect similar to the one seen in Experiment 1 was found for procedural problems. The results from the two experiments suggest that the benefits of animations are not obvious and that in order to determine whether animations can truly aid understanding, teachers and researchers should consider a careful task analysis ahead of time to determine the specific pieces of knowledge that an animation can help a learner acquire and/or practice.
منابع مشابه
Using Animations to Learn about Algorithms: An Ethnographic Case Study
A number of studies have found that using animation for explaining dynamic systems had less bene cial e ects on learning than hoped. Those results come as a surprise to many instructors and students in computer science where animation is becoming an increasingly popular tool for teaching algorithms. This study takes an ethnomethodological approach, observing students using animations and other ...
متن کاملHow Algorithm Animations Aid Learning in Computer Algorithm Education
It has been widely accepted in computer science education (CSE) community that algorithm animations (AA) can help students enhance their understanding to computer algorithms. And since the early eighties there have been lots of efforts being made to develop AA systems. However, the later accumulated empirical studies on the effectiveness of AA have shown that the results are mixed at best. The ...
متن کاملAssessment of the Effect of Educational Animations in Physiology and Anatomy Teaching on Occupational Health Students’ Learning
0
متن کاملEvaluating animations as student aids in learning computer algorithms
We conducted two experiments designed to examine whether animations of algorithms would help students learn the algorithms more effectively. Across the two studies we used two different algorithms--depth-first search and binomial heaps--and used two different subject populations-students with little or no computer science background and students who were computer science majors--and examined wh...
متن کاملAugmenting Worked-Out Examples by Pictorial Representations: When Do They Aid Learning?
In this paper we investigate the effects of different kinds of computer-based visualizations on the acquisition of problemsolving skills in the domain of probability theory. Learners received either purely text-based worked examples, text plus an instruction to mentally imagine the examples’ contents, or they could retrieve either static pictures or concrete animations that depicted the problem...
متن کامل